Page 1
Normal humidity in the
airways
While nose breathing at rest,
inspired gases become heated to 36°C and are about 80%
to 90% saturated with water vapor by the time they
reach the carina, largely due to heat transfer in the
nose. Mouth breathing reduces this to 60% to 70%
relative humidity. Heat and moisture content falls from
carina to nares, so that the nose is typically at 30°C.
A countercurrent mechanism of heat and moisture exchange
in the airways maximizes efficiency, with nasal cooling
on inspiration and warming on exhalation. On very cold
days while exercising a dripping nose is evidence of
this. Tracheal temperature and humidity fall with
increased ventilation particularly when the inspired
gases are cold and dry.
Heat and Water Loss
If totally dry gases were
inspired and fully saturated gases exhaled the total
water loss from ventilation at rest would be about 300
ml/day in the average adult. Normally about half is
retained thanks to the efficiency of the nose (30%
saving) and the humidity of inspired room air (25%
saving). Bypassing the nose with an ETT and not
humidifying gases cases maximal losses.
Non-respiratory water losses
are typically 300 to 600 ml/day but are increased if
warm moist surfaces are exposed (i.e. burns, open abdomen)
particularly if the operating theatre is cold and has
high flow air conditioning.
Heat losses are the result of
four primary processes:
-
Radiation 40% (depends on clothing; 4th power of
absolute temp diff 10°C = 18%)
-
Convection 30% (increased in windy environments)
-
Evaporation 20% (i.e., from skin)
-
Respiration 10% NB: 8% water evaporation,
2%heating Air
Respiratory losses of both heat
and water increase with increased ventilation,
hyperthermia, and dry inspired gases.
ADVANTAGES OF HUMIDIFICATION
Reduced heat loss
Heat loss from warming inspired
air from 20°C to 37 °C:
= Ventilation x Specific
Heat Air x Temp rise
= 7 liter min-1 x 1.2 Joule litre-1°C x 17 °C
= 142.8 Joule min-1 (or 8.6 k Joule per hour or
2.38 watts)
Thus warming the inspired air
from 20 °C requires only about 3% of the body's normal
heat production and at maximum could only cool a
non-heat producing body mass by 0.035 °C per hour.
Heat loss from humidifying
exhaled air fully saturated at 37 °C:
= Ventilation x Water
required x Specific latent heat of vaporization
= 5 liter min-1 x 44 mg litre-1 x 2.4 M Joule kg-1
= 528 Joule min-1 (or 31.7 k Joule per hour or 8.8
watts)
Hence in the worst case
(completely dry inspired gases and, no countercurrent
benefits), humidification about 11.3% of the body's heat
production. Thus fully humidifying completely dry warm
air requires four times as much heat as warming it
alone. Even so, in the worst case at rest, the total
rate of body cooling would be only 0.16 °C per hour from
ventilation. If a 70% efficient HME was used the total
heat loss would only be 0.05 °C per hour and the total
heat loss from ventilation over a 10 hour period would
be only half a degree. In contrast, rapidly infusing one
liter of water at 20 °C would cool the patient by 0.3 °C
almost immediately.
Note that respiratory heat loss
increases if the inspired air is very cold or
ventilation is increased considerably, for example
exercise at high altitudes.
Very importantly neonates and
infants have metabolic rates (and hence ventilatory
requirements) approximately 2 to 3 times that of adults
on a weight basis. They stand to lose a lot more heat
relative to their heat capacity (body mass) and hence
will cool down 2 to 3 times quicker from ventilation.
Neonates stand to lose 0.3 to 0.5 °C per hour from
respiratory heat loss (more if hyperventilated) unless
gases are humidified.
Consequently in adults either
70% humidification of inspired gases for 10 hours or no
humidification for 3 hours result in possible total
temperature falls of only 0.5 °C. Radiant heat loss and
heat loss from room temperature fluid infusions far
exceeds this is clinical practice. Unless there are
other potential or actual problems with hypothermia, or
to avoid excessive drying of secretions, using any form
of humidification in adults for procedures of 2 to 3
hours duration is unjustified, in my opinion.
In neonates, however,
respiratory heat loss may be significant even during
short periods of ventilation.
A small but important practical
point is that body temperature should be measures from a
wedged nasal rather than esophageal temperature probe,
as esophageal probes tend to measure endotracheal tube
rather than patient temperature.
Reduced water loss
During anesthesia it is easy
to replace the small respiratory water loss with iv
fluids. Prolonged extreme exertion as in fun runs and
mountaineering may cause significant dehydration from
respiration and adequate fluid intake is essential.
Prevention of cilia damage
and reduced drying of secretions
Cilia paralysis and reduced
rates of mucus flow occur below 50% relative humidity at
37 °C, but how long it takes for irreversible and/or
significant changes is not known. During brief general
anesthetics this is not a problem. Prolonged severe
dehydration of the bronchial tree leads to encrustation
of mucus and bronchial or endotracheal obstruction,
particularly in neonates and patients with respiratory
infection.
Recommendations for
humidification of inspired gases on this basis are
generally anecdotal.
Microbial Filtration
Some HME's incorporate
viral/bacterial filters.
Disadvantages
Disconnection
All humidifiers increase the
component count in the breathing circuit and increase
the risk of disconnection. Heated humidifiers commonly
require actively heated delivery tubes and these may be
heavy and bulky or use non-standard connectors. Much
less of a problem with HME's although some have
non-standard connectors or are quite bulky.
Overheating
An uncommon event with modern
servo controlled active humidifiers, although burns from
the delivery hose have been recently reported.
Impossible with HME's.
Overhydration
Usually only a problem with
nebulizer type devices. Impossible with HME's.
Circuit resistance,
dead space, and circuit compliance changes
Most modern HME's cause a small
increase in resistance to gas flow, typically 2 cm H20
at 40 l/min (a typical inspiratory flow rate during
anesthesia). Obstruction of HME's with mucus or as a
result of expansion of saturated heat exchanging
material may occur and can result in dangerous increases
in resistance. Heater humidifiers also increase circuit
resistance but usually to a lesser extent (provided
that tubing of adequate diameter is used).
Bubble-through humidifiers cause obvious increases in
resistance. Rain-out may cause obstruction of breathing
tubes.
Dead space considerations in
HME's limit their performance but not their clinical
utility. Greater mass of heat exchanging material
improves performance (especially with larger tidal
volumes) but the dead space increases as well, so usually
it is necessary to choose the right size HME to suit the
patient.
Increased circuit compliance is
important to consider when ventilating neonates.
Infection
Not a problem with disposable
HME's, but can occur in ICU with the water bath of
heated humidifiers.
Drowning
Possible on tilting the water
bath of some heater humidifiers, particularly for
neonates on continuous flow circuits. Can't occur with
HME's.
Interference with other
devices
Excessive humidity in the
proximal breathing circuit from heated humidifiers may
interfere with sampling (side-stream) type CO2 analyzers
and condensation may affect the reading on some tidal
volume meters. Rain-out from active humidifiers may be a
considerable problem, particularly in ICU's.
Inadequate humidification
HME's are probably inadequate
for:
-
Prolonged ICU use, i.e. more than 2 to 3 days
-
More than 6 hours or so where respiratory
secretions are a problem
-
Warming cold patients
-
Hyperventilation.
Active heater humidifiers can
provide 100% relative humidity at 37 °C or more for
prolonged periods and are preferable in the above
situations
Cost
Disposable HME's cost $2.00 to
$7.00 per patient. A F&P type dome costs $25.00, and as
well as the capital cost of the base, the delivery tube
will have to be sterilized at the end of the case.
METHODS OF HUMIDIFYING
INSPIRED GASES
Anesthetic circuits
Water's to and fro type systems
generate warm moist gases but are little used these
days. Bain type circuits result in both countercurrent
heating of the inspired gases and re-breathing of exhaled
gas for some humidification, but they probably only are
about 10% to 20% efficient on IPPV and even less when
used for spontaneous breathing (because of the high
fresh gas flows required). Circle circuits warm up after
a period of time and do generate water but again are
relatively little help.
Nebulizers
Rarely used these days
as the nebulization process results in an inhaled aerosol of
100% relative humidity at lower than room temperature,
which increases heat loss rather than reducing it. Water
uptake may be excessive and there is a real potential
for infection from the water bath. Used only to liquefy
secretions, but these days active humidification is far
preferable.
Heat and Moisture Exchangers
(HME's)
Initially made for
tracheotomy patients from copper mesh ("Swedish
nose"). Now most are cheap and disposable and made from
modified hygroscopic paper filters encased in a plastic
case.
HME's are usually 50% to 80%
efficient at best (depending on inspired humidity),
consequently heat and water loss and dehydration of
respiratory secretions still occur, particularly if the
inspired gases are completely dry. Efficiency is reduced
further by large tidal volumes or by failure to place
the HME right on the endotracheal tube, permitting
rain-out. Full function is not immediate, typically
taking 5 to 20 minutes to achieve steady state.
None the less they are almost
as effective as the human nose and provide enough
humidification to maintain ciliary action and mucus flow
and to reduce heat and moisture losses during
anesthesia to insignificant levels. The Pall filter is
also one of the best bacterial filters on the market.
They are simple to use, cheap, act as a macroscopic
particle trap and avoid many of the problems associated
with active humidifiers.
Active Heated Humidifiers
These electrically powered
heated water bath devices are capable of fully
saturating and heating inspired gases to 37 °C at high
flow rates flow rates (i.e. to 60 l/min) and in this
regard are far superior to HME's. A heated delivery hose
is required to prevent cooling and loss of humidity in
the inspiratory limb of the circuit. Sterile single use
water chambers with wicks are common, and some are
automatically filled from a water reservoir.
They have many disadvantages,
including cost, storage requirements, servicing, circuit
complexity, water rain-out leading to monitor
malfunction or tubing occlusion, extra risk of
disconnection, infection hazard, potential for burns and
drowning, and altered circuit compliance.
However I think they are
definitely required for ICU patients who need
hyperventilation for prolonged periods, particularly for
neonatal and small children. In my opinion the rationale
has little to do with heat loss, or even prevention of
ciliary dysfunction. The main benefit is to ensure that
there is no net evaporation of water from secretions
that lodge in the lumen of the endotracheal tube, so
that they do not become dehydrated and encrusted and
lead to obstruction.
What is Humidity?
The prevention of
cellular dehydration is a primary human
homeostatic requirement. Complex and reliable
mechanisms exist to maintain overall fluid
balance.
Skin and other
integuments are relatively impermeable to
moisture, reducing evaporative water loss and
consequent cooling. Special problems occur with
specialized tissues (i.e., cornea, airways,
lungs), and under abnormal conditions (e.g.,
burns, surgical procedures, some illnesses).
Anesthetists need to
maintain both global fluid balance and local
tissue needs during anesthesia. The purpose of
this talk is to generally review evaporative
water loss and consequent heat loss during
anesthesia, with particular emphasis on how
this can be influenced by humidification of
breathing circuit gases.
DEFINITIONS &
PHYSICS
Vapor
Gas phase of a
substance which is normally a liquid at ambient
temperature and pressure.
Dalton's Law
The pressure exerted by
a mixture of gases or vapors enclosed in a
given space equals the sum of the partial
pressures that each gas or vapor would exert if
it alone occupied the same space.
Saturated Vapor
Pressure (SVP)
The saturated vapor
pressure of a liquid is the partial pressure of
the vapor above its liquid state at
equilibrium, and is very dependent on the type
of liquid and its temperature.
If a volatile liquid is
introduced into a closed container, the pressure
in the container will increase in proportion to
the partial pressure of the vapor. In an
expansible system the volume of gas increases (if
the temperature is unchanged) because of the
addition of the vapor and all constituents are
proportionally diluted.
The SVP of water at
37°C is 47mmHg and contains 44mg/l of water
whereas at room temperature (20°C) it is 20mmHg
and contains only 18 mg/l).
|
SVP at
|
0°C
|
20°C
|
37°C
|
|
Temperature (°C) |
0
|
20
|
37
|
|
SVP (mmHg)
|
6
|
20
|
47
|
|
Content
(mg/l) |
5
|
18
|
44
|
|
Table 1: Water Vapor,
temperature, and SVP at 0, 20,
and 37°C. |
|
Absolute Humidity
The absolute amount of
water vapor in a gas expressed in either mg/l
of gas mixture or mmHg (partial pressure) .
Relative Humidity
Amount of water vapor
in a gas expressed as a percentage of that which
could be held by the gas if it were fully
saturated at the same temperature, i.e.:
Relative Humidity. =
Actual Water Content / Water Content Fully
Saturated %, or
Absolute Humidity = Actual Vapor Pressure /
Saturated Vapor Pressure %
Relative Humidity is
the common description of humidity used in
weather reports as it correlates best with our
perception of dryness or moistness of the air.
Heat
Heat is a form of
energy that can be transferred from a warmer
object to a cooler one and is related to the
kinetic energy of vibration of molecules. Its
units are Joules. 4.18 Joules equal one calorie
and will raise one gram of water one degree
centigrade. Total body heat production is about
80 Watts (i.e. Joules per second) for the average
person (or 288 kJ/hr, 7,000 kJ/day, or
about1,700 kcal/day). Shivering can increase
heat production up to four-fold, and exercise
even more.
Specific Heat
Specific heat is the
amount of heat required to raise the temperature
of 1 kg of a substance by one degree Kelvin (the
same as one degree centigrade); the units are
Joules Kg-1
degK-1. The
specific heat of water is 4.18 KJ per kg per °C,
but it is often written as 1 kcal or 1 Cal Kg-1
°C-1.
Calories and calories should no longer be used.
The specific heat of air is only 1.2 J litre-1
°C-1.
i.e. 1/500th that of water.
Heat Capacity
This refers to the
amount of heat required to raise the temperature
of an object by one degree Kelvin. For a 70 kg
patient this is about 245kJ per °C. As basal
heat production is about 280kJ/hr it takes a
little less than 1hour to passively raise core
temperature of a patient 1°C even if all losses
are prevented.
Specific Latent Heat
of Evaporation
The heat required to
convert 1 kg of a liquid to its vapor at a
given temperature. For water this is about 2.4
M Joules per kg at body temperature and only
slightly greater at room temperature.
MEASUREMENT OF
HUMIDITY
Generally speaking this
is very difficult.
Psychrometer
A system using two
thermometers, one with a wet and the other a dry
bulb. Air movement over the wet bulb causes
evaporative cooling generating a difference in
temperature readings. This difference relates to
the rate of airflow over the wet bulb and the
relative humidity. Tables are used to look up
the relative humidity from the two temperatures,
however there is a high degree of inaccuracy.
When the relative humidity is 100% there is no
temperature difference.
Dewpoint Hygrometer
Using a precisely
cooled shiny plate the user observes the
temperature at which condensation first occurs.
At this temperature the gas is fully saturated
with water hence both the water content and the
relative humidity at any other temperature can
be ascertained from a vapor pressure table.
Weighing Water
By weighing anhydrous
silica before and after exposure to a known
volume of sample gas the water content of the
sample can be determined. The silica must be
kept away from other sources of moisture during
weighing, and in practice this is a cumbersome
and tedious technique.
The performance of
active humidifiers is most simply tested by
measuring the outlet temperature, the amount of
water consumed per unit time, and the gas flow.
The relative humidity at the outlet of the
humidifier under test (at this temperature and
gas flow) can be established from the number of
milligrams of water taken up per liter of gas.
For example, 10 l/min at 37°C results in 600
liters of gas flow over one hour, and if each
takes up 44 mg/l (to be fully saturated at this
temperature), 26.4g of water should have been
used over the hour. If only 20mg was taken up,
the relative humidity was 20/26.4 or 75.8%.
Mass Spectroscopy
Mass Spectroscopy can
be very accurate but only if condensation
(rain-out) does not occur in the sample line.
This is the best technique for assessing
"in-circuit" humidity as it can assess breath by
breath changes.
Humidity Transducers
Special transducers are
available in which the electrical conductivity of
a membrane changes with water vapor pressure
are available.